Wenzel v.
Boyles Galvanizing
Co.,
920 F. 2d
778 (11th Cir. Fla. 1991).
Plaintiffs
were working on the 135th foot level of the Straton Energy
Center. As they began to break the thin strip of metal binding a bundle
of steel, it sprung open causing them both to fall and sustain serious
injuries. Plaintiffs sued the architect, construction manager and others
for their injuries. The jury returned a verdict in favor of plaintiffs
for a combined total of approximately two million seven hundred fifty
thousand. Defendants appealed.
Ms.
Lippincott represented the plaintiffs on appeal. The United States
Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeal affirmed the judgment, ruling that: 1)
an exculpatory clause in the construction management contract was
insufficient to relieve defendants from liability; 2) the issue of
whether the construction manager should have required its subcontractors
to use safety nets was an issue for the jury; 3) the trial court did not
err in refusing to permit defendants to introduce evidence on the
apportionment of damages; 4) defendants were not acting as the
employer’s safety consultant so as to immunize them from suit pursuant
to the workers compensation law.